Browns QB Watson remains on PUP list, will not play in 2025 season

Deshaun Watson will not play in the 2025 season after failing to be activated from the physically unable to perform (PUP) list, marking a significant setback for the Cleveland Browns.

Why it matters: This decision firmly establishes Shedeur Sanders as the starting quarterback for the Browns moving forward, representing a shift in the team's strategy and immediate future.

  • With Watson's absence confirmed, the Browns will continue to rely on Sanders, who has been starting for the last five games.
  • As the team navigates this transition, they must evaluate how their offensive schemes can adapt to maximize Sanders' potential.

What’s new: The deadline to activate Watson was Tuesday, coinciding with the closure of his practice window.

  • Head Coach Kevin Stefanski expressed confidence in Watson's efforts during rehabilitation, stating, "He's done a great job with everything that's been asked of him... Just felt like this was the right decision for him and for us."
  • Watson underwent two surgeries following a torn Achilles tendon sustained in October 2024, complicating his path back to the field.

By the numbers: Watson’s recent performance has not matched expectations given his substantial contract.

  • He has played only 19 games since joining the Browns in March 2022, contributing to a Total QBR of 33.1, ranking him just above rookie Cam Ward of the Tennessee Titans.
  • The Browns are currently sitting at a disappointing 3-12 record, with a mere 24.2% chance of securing the No. 1 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Yes, but: The financial implications of Watson's contract loom large over the franchise.

  • Watson is due $46 million next season, with a staggering cap hit of $80.7 million in 2026, which is the largest in the NFL.
  • Cutting him before June 1 would result in a historic dead cap charge of $131 million, surpassing the previous high set by Russell Wilson at $85 million.

The big picture: The Browns investment in Watson has drawn scrutiny from both fans and management.

  • Team owner Jimmy Haslam described the Watson trade as “a big swing-and-miss,” reflecting the growing frustration around the quarterback's impact on the franchise.
  • This discontent is compounded by Watson serving an 11-game suspension due to allegations of sexual assault and inappropriate conduct earlier in his tenure with the team.

What’s next: The Browns need to assess their long-term plans at quarterback amid Watson's ongoing recovery and performance issues.

  • As Sanders leads the team, the front office may explore options for bolstering the quarterback position in upcoming drafts or free agency.
  • The evolving situation surrounding Watson will likely influence the Browns' draft strategy and overall direction heading into the 2026 season.

The bottom line: Watson’s inability to return to form places significant pressure on the Browns to recalibrate their roster and game plan, especially as they search for stability and success in the coming seasons.

whiproute logo