Dolphins fire HC McDaniel after disappointing 8-9 season, ending playoff hopes

The Miami Dolphins have fired head coach Mike McDaniel after two seasons, signaling a need for significant change within the organization.

Why it matters: This decision reflects the Dolphins' disappointing trajectory, having missed the playoffs for the first time under McDaniel with an 8-9 record in 2024.

  • The team has now experienced back-to-back losing seasons following playoff appearances in 2022 and 2023.
  • Owner Stephen Ross emphasized that "comprehensive change" was necessary after thorough evaluations of the team's performance.

What’s new: McDaniel's termination comes just months after he signed a three-year extension in August 2024.

  • His firing marks a notable shift as he had led the Dolphins to impressive offensive rankings, finishing sixth in total offense in 2022 and leading the NFL in 2023.
  • Despite these achievements, the decline in the team’s success this season ultimately cost him his job.

Yes, but: While McDaniel showcased creativity on offense, inconsistency plagued the Dolphins, particularly in 2024.

  • Quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, who led the league in passing yards in 2023 with 4,624 yards, struggled with injuries this past season, missing six games.
  • The offense faltered significantly, illustrated by the Dolphins’ early struggles where they lost six of their first eight games.

What to watch: The future of Tua Tagovailoa may now be uncertain following McDaniel's exit.

  • With Tagovailoa's substantial cap hit of $56.4 million in 2026 and potential dead cap implications, the Dolphins face challenging decisions regarding his long-term viability as their starting quarterback.
  • Tagovailoa expressed openness to a fresh start, indicating that the organizational shake-up could be an opportunity for reinvention.

The bottom line: McDaniel's departure adds to the Dolphins' history of instability at the head coaching position, marking the third head coach in ten seasons.

  • No coach has completed four full seasons since Dave Wannstedt left the franchise in 2003.
  • As the Dolphins seek a new leader, the focus will also turn to how they can revitalize their roster to regain competitive standing in the AFC.
whiproute logo
Dolphins fire HC McDaniel after disappointing 8-9 season, ending playoff hopes