Giants' Carter benched after sleeping during walk-through, coach Kafka addresses situation

The New York Giants benched first-round pick Abdul Carter for the opening series of their game against the Green Bay Packers after reports surfaced that he slept during a walk-through practice.

Why it matters: This incident has raised questions about accountability and professionalism within the Giants' organization, particularly for a player expected to step into a starting role due to injury.

Carter, selected with the No. 3 overall pick in the draft, was expected to replace injured linebacker Kayvon Thibodeaux in the lineup. Instead, Tomon Fox started in his place, playing the first six defensive snaps before the Packers punted.

What’s new: Reports indicated that Carter was benched due to sleeping through a walk-through, but he claims he was receiving treatment at the time.

• Carter's statement: "I own the fact that it was an honest mistake. I was getting treatment and I told Coach Kafka that, too.”
• He emphasized that this was not a recurring issue, asserting, "This was the only time it happened."

Yes, but: Coach Mike Kafka opted to change practice times without notifying Carter, which contributed to the misunderstanding.

• The adjustment in schedule may have created confusion for Carter, who stated, "I did not realize [the change] until it was too late."

What to watch: As the season progresses, how the Giants manage player discipline and communication will be crucial for team cohesion and performance.

• Kafka declined to provide further comments on the situation, signaling a desire to keep internal matters private.

Between the lines: While Carter accepted responsibility for the incident, the surrounding circumstances highlight potential flaws in the team's logistical operations.

• Kafka's reluctance to discuss the matter publicly suggests a commitment to maintaining a unified front, but it also leaves room for speculation about broader issues within the organization.

The bottom line: The Giants must address both player accountability and effective communication if they hope to maximize the talent of their high-profile draft picks like Carter, especially as they navigate a challenging season ahead.