Posted on Sep 09

Giants LB Micah McFadden will undergo foot surgery, expected to miss significant time

Posted Sep 9, 2025

The New York Giants will be without starting linebacker Micah McFadden for an extended period due to a foot injury requiring surgery.

Why it matters: McFadden's absence is a significant blow to the Giants' defensive unit, which relies heavily on his ability to provide tackling and coverage support in modern NFL schemes.

As a full-time starter in 2023, he has been instrumental in the Giants’ defensive strategy, often playing a crucial role in both run defense and pass coverage.
His injury not only impacts the team’s immediate performance but also raises concerns about depth at the linebacker position as they navigate their schedule.

What’s new: The injury occurred during a game against the Washington Commanders when McFadden tackled quarterback Jayden Daniels.

Following the collision, McFadden was seen leaving the field with his right leg in an air cast, indicating the seriousness of the injury.
Darius Muasau stepped in as his replacement and faced immediate pressure from the Commanders' offense, resulting in a touchdown pass to tight end Zach Ertz.

By the numbers: McFadden has been a reliable force since joining the Giants, starting 14 games in both of his previous two seasons and recording over 100 tackles each year.

Last season, he set a career-high with 107 tackles, showcasing his growth as a player after being drafted in the fifth round of the 2022 NFL Draft.
As this is the final year of his rookie contract, the stakes are high for McFadden to return strong post-surgery.

Yes, but: While McFadden's injury creates a hole in the lineup, the Giants have shown resilience and adaptability in the past.

Muasau, though relatively inexperienced, will have the opportunity to step up, potentially gaining valuable experience that could benefit him and the team in the long run.
In today's NFL, it’s common for teams to face injuries; how the Giants respond will be telling of their overall depth and coaching effectiveness.

What’s next: McFadden’s surgery will dictate his recovery timeline, and the Giants will need to adjust their game plan accordingly.

The coaching staff must evaluate how to maximize the talents of Muasau while mitigating the impact of losing McFadden’s presence on the field.
Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see if Muasau can fill the significant void left by McFadden and how the defense adapts in upcoming games.

The bottom line: McFadden's injury is a tough setback for the Giants, but it also presents an opportunity for the team to showcase its depth and resilience.

As the Giants aim to remain competitive in a challenging NFC East, how they manage this situation will be critical in shaping their season moving forward.

Giants LB Micah McFadden will undergo foot surgery, expected to miss significant time

Alex Parker

Posted Sep 9, 2025

The New York Giants will be without starting linebacker Micah McFadden for an extended period due to a foot injury requiring surgery.

Why it matters: McFadden's absence is a significant blow to the Giants' defensive unit, which relies heavily on his ability to provide tackling and coverage support in modern NFL schemes.

As a full-time starter in 2023, he has been instrumental in the Giants’ defensive strategy, often playing a crucial role in both run defense and pass coverage.

His injury not only impacts the team’s immediate performance but also raises concerns about depth at the linebacker position as they navigate their schedule.

What’s new: The injury occurred during a game against the Washington Commanders when McFadden tackled quarterback Jayden Daniels.

Following the collision, McFadden was seen leaving the field with his right leg in an air cast, indicating the seriousness of the injury.

Darius Muasau stepped in as his replacement and faced immediate pressure from the Commanders' offense, resulting in a touchdown pass to tight end Zach Ertz.

By the numbers: McFadden has been a reliable force since joining the Giants, starting 14 games in both of his previous two seasons and recording over 100 tackles each year.

Last season, he set a career-high with 107 tackles, showcasing his growth as a player after being drafted in the fifth round of the 2022 NFL Draft.

As this is the final year of his rookie contract, the stakes are high for McFadden to return strong post-surgery.

Yes, but: While McFadden's injury creates a hole in the lineup, the Giants have shown resilience and adaptability in the past.

Muasau, though relatively inexperienced, will have the opportunity to step up, potentially gaining valuable experience that could benefit him and the team in the long run.

In today's NFL, it’s common for teams to face injuries; how the Giants respond will be telling of their overall depth and coaching effectiveness.

What’s next: McFadden’s surgery will dictate his recovery timeline, and the Giants will need to adjust their game plan accordingly.

The coaching staff must evaluate how to maximize the talents of Muasau while mitigating the impact of losing McFadden’s presence on the field.

Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see if Muasau can fill the significant void left by McFadden and how the defense adapts in upcoming games.

The bottom line: McFadden's injury is a tough setback for the Giants, but it also presents an opportunity for the team to showcase its depth and resilience.

As the Giants aim to remain competitive in a challenging NFC East, how they manage this situation will be critical in shaping their season moving forward.